• Receivables Podcast
  • April 4, 2024

Pollack & Rosen, P.A. | Michael A. Gold Shares His Experience in Class Action Defense | Ep 169

Summary: Litigation defense for creditors and debt buyers is the focus as Michael A. Gold, Litigation Defense Attorney at Pollack & Rosen, P.A., joins Adam Parks on Receivables Roundtable. Gold traces his path from criminal defense to attorney fee litigation for large debt buyers in Florida, explains why 12 months of account statements matter at trial, and outlines his role coordinating defense litigation across 16 states.

Key Takeaways

  • Gold's debt buyer work began around 2015 with attorney fee litigation, including cases where a roughly $1,200 credit card balance produced about $24,000 in consumer defense attorney fees.
  • He tells clients to obtain 12 months of statements rather than only the last statement and the charge-off statement, because a fuller history disproves defense theories such as no meeting of the minds.
  • Gold describes Florida as probably the most litigious state in the industry, with the same four or five consumer defense attorneys appearing in cases across the state.
  • Pollack & Rosen has a footprint with law firms in about 16 states, and Gold was brought on to help direct and coordinate defense litigation throughout the country.
  • One client gave him 300 cases last year, and by November only 10 remained after wins, settlements or dismissals, which he says shows defense attorneys retreat when cases are litigated fully.

Tune in for a chat with Michael Gold, Litigation Defense Attorney at Pollack & Rosen, P.A., about trends and issues he has encountered in Class Action Defense cases while representing creditors and debt buyers. Michael is a seasoned litigator with specialized expertise in financial, securities fraud, and class action defense and the newest addition to the Pollack & Rosen Litigation Defense Division.

Your 10-Minute Weekly Receivables Industry Update

Subscribe to the Receivables Info newsletter for key receivables industry news, debt collection updates, compliance developments, and industry events.

Listen on Your Favorite Platform

Read Podcast Transcript

Hello, everybody. Adam Parks here with another episode of Receivables Roundtable. Today, I’m here with my new friend, Mr. Michael A. Gold, who has recently joined the Pollock and Rosen firm down in Miami. How you doing today, Michael? I’m doing well. Thanks for having me. Well, I’m really getting the opportunity. I feel like the first look to get to know you here. And I really appreciate you coming on. I know the folks over at Pollock and Rosen really well, but this is the first time that you and I have had a chance to catch up. Could you tell myself and the audience a little bit about yourself and how you got to the seat that

you’re in today? Sure, I guess, you know, I just started with literally with Pollock and Rosen yesterday. But to go, I mean, literally, but although I’ve in and out, but to go backwards a little bit, I’m a Florida boy born and bred, went ended up going to University South Florida, graduated with a finance degree, left Florida never to come back and got inspired to go to law school. And at the age, what was it 28? I decided to go to law school. I went to law school down in Miami called St. Thomas University. At the time I started, they weren’t even accredited. They were provisionally, but they said I could take the bar and I’m like,

I’m in. Did well, I graduated. I was first in my class. The first year was the book and then graduated with high honors. From there, I decided to go to Georgetown and get a master’s of law degree in securities and financial regulations. So I did that graduated with honors from there. And I ended up coming back to Florida, got married while I was at Georgetown. And I had passed the bar Florida. My ex wife lived in Florida or her family lived in Florida. That’s where I met her. So we went came back to Florida to work. My first job was working for a lawyer named Barry Cohen. And if anybody’s been around in

the east of Florida, and Barry Cohen is very high, was a very high profile criminal defense attorney. So I started out doing criminal defense for and I did a work for Barry for about 12 years. Worked on some cases. One case that I always mentioned is the Sabrina Eisenberg case, which had national publicity. They were on Oprah. There’s there’s a CNN special on it. And Yaddia. So I spent a lot of time in federal court doing a lot of white collar criminal defense. A lot of mortgage, a part of the time there was when the mortgage crisis happened and the government was collecting mortgage. And then I

ended up coming to work or going to work at a firm called Walters Levine. And at the time it was Walters Levine, clean his Smith and Thomas and stuff like that. About 2015, and I’ve been there, but about 2000 for a couple years, six or seven years, but 2015, my boss got connected with I don’t know if I can’t I can’t say, Midland funding. And they hired us to do work on attorney fee litigation. Based on all these collection efforts and and they were having issues with the title meant. And my boss said, you handle it, Michael, since then it grew, I did so well sort of defending entitlement and

coming up with theories on how to beat, you know, the amount of fees or reasonableness of the fees, you know, we had cases they were showing where is a $1,200 credit card chart and they were the defense bar was getting $24,000 in attorney fees. So we started really at getting pushing back on that came up with some theories that have been used by others. And it and it huh, excuse me. And it got to the point where they said, well, why don’t you handle the underlying cases for us? So I started getting cases where the certain defense bar showed up. And I don’t know if you know, Florida, Florida’s, as everybody

tells me is probably in this industry, the most litigious state in the union. There’s a lot, you know, and there’s a lot of guys defense attorneys out there attempting to get their fees paid by the debt buyers. So I started litigating the underlying cases and got really successful with that. I haven’t lost a trial, not go with it. But so I just grew and I got to the point where where people I’m sorry about that, where other companies start to call it Florida, who do we want to hire? My name came up and I started and my practice grew and I have now seven or eight, you

know, I did I had seven or eight of the of the large debt buyers who when certain defense attorneys showed up, I’d get a call leader from them or for their under you know, the collection agency and they say, Hey, can you handle the case? And I’ve been doing that. In January this year, I decided it was time for me to move on. I just, I think I had run my course in my firm. And I needed something different, more of a challenge. And that’s how I ended up at Pollack and Rosen. And so now I’m at Pollack and Rosen. My job I hope to continue in Florida to

litigate some some of these cases still. I mean, I’ve talked to a few of my former clients and said, when we get new cases, we want to send them to you. And we want, you know, we want you to be a part of our team. So I hopefully will be able to litigate these cases in Florida. But the the bigger project and really why I was brought on at Pollack and Rosen is to help direct and coordinate defense litigation throughout the country. Pollack and Rosen currently has a footprint with law firms in about 16 states. And they’re looking for somebody with my kind of experience to help the attorney in Ohio or

whatever state it may be, you know, hey, this issue, I got this attorney is a real problem, or I got this attorney keeps my class actions are not this attorney who does this. Okay, here’s what we need to do. All right. And so I’m hoping to translate what it is I do what it is I’ve learned in my nine years litigating in this field to to other states and hopefully bring, you know, some order back in the chaos that arises from time to time. It’s a very interesting approach, because when you think about a creditors rights firm, you don’t often think about the litigation defense support, you know, type of role, and it

sounds like you’re taking on a very kind of a groundbreaking approach to a age old problem. Well, that’s what excited me about the job. And and really, I be honest, I had several offers when I left. But this one sort of put, you know, gave me this opportunity, not only to do what it is I enjoy doing and I’ve been doing and I’ve been in my opinion doing well, but to help spread the word so to speak, I’ve, you know, actually in the past, I’ve had some of the the debt buyers I think research and I did a four part lecture series lecture series where they had all their in house counsel, all

their out house counsel. And, you know, I grew up, my mother was a teacher. I like teaching I coach my kids in soccer as they grew up. So it I do enjoy, Hey, let’s figure it out. You know, what do you think? Well, what can we do? Here’s my ideas. And, you know, to be honest, over the last nine years, I’ve I’ve I’ve gained a lot of experience and a lot of issues that when they came to me, people didn’t really know how to handle, you know, what to do. And because of my background, being a criminal defense lawyer, I didn’t come into this and I didn’t look at

these cases as a credit or rights organization or even a collection age. And I came in and I’m a litigator. I’m okay. And it was, these are the issues, these are the issues I see, what are we going to do with it? And so it wasn’t okay, you know, I want to make sure I collect my money. I want my goal was to make sure that attorney that’s on the other side and causing havoc realizes this is a losing proposition and he finds another line of work and another source of income. And you know, that’s really been my MO and and what I’ve done for like I said, the last nine years.

It’s incredible. It’s it’s a it’s something that’s very needed from a collection standpoint, right? There’s always the I’m going to throw up the air quotes, what I call the consumer attorneys that are just out to litigate. And I know in the end, the consumers seeing very little of that to begin with, right? And we’re just patting the attorney’s pockets and, you know, their strategies have moved very much online in terms of generating the opportunities for business that they’re finding and they’re using all kinds of subpar strategies from what I’m seeing from an SEO standpoint and online standpoint in order to generate those opportunities to communicate with a consumer and convince them to

mitigate or to sue the collector versus paying them regardless of whether or not the debt is owed. I find that to be distasteful in general. But hey, that’s the business line that they’ve chosen. Well, it reminds me a little, you know, you get in trouble criminally, you get a DUI or what you’re going to get 15 letters from 15 lawyers. Hey, I’ll rep excuse me, I’ll represent you. These guys, it’s and it’s really the guys that are good at it at that figuring out how to use via social media or, or, you know, internet or whatever. There’s the same three, four, five people you see all over the state. And they went,

you know, there’s two or three firms down in Miami, but I see them in Alachua County, which is Gainesville, which is north of me and I’m in Tampa. I see him in Tampa. I see him. There’s a guy in his guy in Tampa. I see him all over the center part of the state. There’s a guy in Jacksonville. I see him far south. And so, but you, you’re most of the people are going to four or five guys. And it’s those four or five guys who have had success, you know, their, their goal, you know, it’s is to be such a nuisance that the plaintiff just wants to settle case, you know, let me

get out. I can get out for two grand. I can get out for three grand, which that’s cool to how I started, you know, there’s an expression I like this is bears and bulls make money and pigs get slaughtered. And these guys back in the day, they were settling cases with the debt buyers for cheap money, $1,000 or whatever it is and in an in a dismissal of the of the of the debt to the consumer. And then they started asking for 1500. Then they started asking for 2000. Then they started asking for 3000. And I think somebody along the way said, okay, we’re spending, you know, this is costing you know, somebody in

underwriting went, yeah, this isn’t going to work for us. You know, we need to do so. And that’s really how I started, you know, got involved and was first brought in. I was somebody else about it. Yeah, well, I mean, at some point when you’re being bullied, you push back, right? Right. And I think a lot of organizations have started pushing back against the bullies because they knew that they were standing, especially as compliance has increased through the years, right? And as the confidence level in the documentation and the underlying supporting documents on any individual account have improved, I think the confidence level in fighting back

against those frivolous suits has definitely driven the industry forward. Well, totally. And I mean, when I started, I’d say, OK, give me your, I call it our original account level documentation. And there’s actually some support for that term. But give me all your information. And they would, the debt buyer, let’s say the credit card case, all they’d have is the last activity statement and the last statement. And in some way, they had the charge off statement. There’s an attorney at Tiappa who was using the charge off statement and getting judgments, getting judges convinced that there was no meeting of the minds as to what was owed because the charge off statement said zero.

I said, you guys need to get 12 months. You need 12. You need a history. And again, it was me coming looking at it from the perspective of a litigator and not a deck collect. And the deck collector is like, I got to laugh. I’m good. They’re comfortable. But if we’re going to go litigate a case, we need to do a little something more because we can go down the litany of issues. When I only have two statements, it’s an issue. But if I’ve got 12 months, I can disprove all those issues. The last three or four trials I’ve had, I’ve had, I’ve cited it to even in front of a bed trial

where I focused in jury when I’m closing argument, the believability of witnesses paragraph. And it’s basically the same throughout the country and federal. I think Florida’s is based on the federal, which basically says you can believe or disbelieve a witness. In addition, you can use common sense and make reasonable inference. There’s two jury instructions. And I go, judge, you’re the trial of fact. You need to listen to what this guy is telling you. And what happens a lot is these guys get trained by the defense attorneys, OK, listen. And you’ve got statements, you may payments, but then all of a sudden you stop got in payment.

You got statements. So you never saw this final statement. So we’re going to say you never saw that final statement. So we will be good. And they’ll never, you know, and they can’t prove one of the elements of the cause of action because there was never a rendering. Well, I go to the witness. Let me see if I get this straight. You lived at 407 Main Street in 2012. And you lived there in 2013. And you lived there in 2014. Yep, yep, yep. You never moved. And you were just getting statements from Synchrony Bank. Yep. And then one day they stopped. Yeah, that’s right. Never got him.

And that was easy. Those were the harder ones. Like, yeah, like a judge. Do you really believe that? You know, I mean, let’s look at the jury and the structure. You really believe that. And so that was a sort of thing that my background sort of brought to the table. I don’t think people were really thinking about it. Because it wasn’t, you know, they’re trying to just do, you know, get out the letter, the demand letters, get that lawsuit filed, get in front of a judge, you know, get the guy into the courtroom and settle the case. Whereas when these attorneys showed up, they really weren’t ready for that.

They were stuck. And I’ve been fortunate in that the firms I was with, and now with my step forward, I get the opportunity to take something that’s, you know, it’s a $1,000 case. And know that this is gonna litigate like it was a $100,000. And what I found too, when people come to me and they said, hey, you know, we’re interested in you. This defense, what do you do? I said, listen, you’re gonna pay me more money today to litigate the case. Cause we’re gonna turn this case on the head. These guys, these defense attorneys, they come at you thinking if they make you work hard enough,

you’ll throw your hands up, give up, give them some money and discharge the debt. Go, no, no, no, we’re gonna make them work for it. We’re gonna make it so that at the end of the day, not only did they not get the debt discharge, they probably got a judgment against their client and they didn’t get a penny. So they did all this work for nothing. And so what’s gonna happen is, yeah, this year, you’re gonna pay me more money, but a year from now, two years from now, those guys are gonna be begging to get out of these cases as quickly and possible and you see it.

You know, I have been a victim of my own success. I had a client, I had, they gave me 300 cases last year. You know, February, March, January, March, January, January, February, March, by November, I had 10. Cause they all either, I won the case, they settled, or, you know, but it was, got rid of it. And so my, you know, my pitch to my clients is don’t let these guys intimidate you. They’re gonna, they throw everything against the wall thinking you’ll get scared. We’re not gonna let that happen. You’re gonna win this case. And that’s what we do. And the biggest shame in all this is,

and I’ve said this to attorneys and their clients like in a mediation, these attorneys will risk a judgment against their client hoping to get attorney’s fees at a later date. And I’ve literally had like taken a depot, I’ve taken the depot with the defendant, the deputy has admitted his debt, admitted he owes the money, admitted he didn’t pay it. And I turned it, turned it, we say, you wanna settle this? No, no, we’re gonna go to trial. Okay. You know, I mean, you’re putting this guy at risk cause you’re greedy. And I think what’s happening too, you’re gonna see that the defense bar is gonna be a little more

the particular about what they bring lawsuits with. And they’re gonna be more inclined to figure out how to make money off the case by, you know, getting $500 from the consumer, as opposed to going, don’t pay them anything. I’m gonna go get the money from them. Those are just not gonna get the money from. I think you and I are fighting the same battle from different perspectives. My, you know, a lot of what I spend my time doing is defending the online reputations of the organizations in the space, the debt buyers, the agencies, the law firms and fighting back against those virtual attacks on a regular basis.

And they are funneling money in and it is a constant struggle in battle where else on the other side, once they have been able to identify some consumers that have a debt with a particular debt collector and have convinced that consumer to move forward with litigating versus paying the debt that they already know they owe, you’re on the other side assisting those agencies in law firms and debt buyers with protecting themselves in the courtroom itself, which I think is just kind of two interesting ends of the same spectrum. I think your job’s probably a lot harder than mine. Yeah, you’re about hard. My mind may be funner.

I like to win. It’s a constant battle. And I think that’s probably the part of it that I enjoy is that constant, it’s a constant game of chess, right? It’s a game of chess with no end. Well, you know, you pretty up a good point, maybe just think about it. When I started in 2015, the CFPB had issued consent orders against the several large consumers, not only the Riashew. So what was happening in 2015 and before is consumers were going into course a judge. Yeah, it was a money, but look what these people are, look what they’ve done to me and look what they did this.

And look at the documents, they don’t have documents. So you were, we were back in the day, when my first few clients, one of the things I had was a chart of counties and judges who we thought was pro-consumer or we thought was not. And it was very lot of real consumers. But I think since that time, the industry as a whole has really turned itself around. I don’t, you know, you see these claims. I got to be playing on that for you. But yeah, and it has. So now I go into court, I’ve had two judges complain about the defense’s litigation tactics. You know, the defense attorneys are the litigation.

And so what I found is nine, you know, while they’re still pro-consumer judges out there and I get it, a 90% of them are at worst, right down the road or as they should be, right down the middle of the road, at best for us, you know, worse maybe, you know, they know this attorney and they know their, you know, this attorney’s just playing a game and they’re not going to put up with it. And I get a judge at West Palm Beach just like that who at this point is like, judge, I want to give you 10. I mean, he doesn’t even, you know, he knows

because I’ve got, I got the documents, you know, where, why would I have all these account statements if I didn’t know the account, right? And all these, it’s not Robosigning fake affidavits. Look, judge, I got 12 months of statements. His name, his address, he’s admitted. He, you know, he’s admitted, these are his. Why are we here? You know, and it goes. And the same thing with Jerry’s. You know, these guys, they’ve stopped. I kind of beat so few, a few of them up on jury tribe. Never understood why they want jury trials, maybe back in 2012, 13, when they could really throw a lot of garbage

at the debt buyer and the collector. Of course, the RMAI certification program. Right. RMAI came out with a certification program that required certain documentation standards to be met in order to purchase accounts by debt buyers. Right. And those new buyers that were certified had to have these things in place, which clearly was for a reason. Right. And so, right. So I, but in that, hey, so I’ve got the documents. I’m comfortable with the documents now. I, you know, there’s some case law in Florida and I’ll be able to find it elsewhere, where I don’t even need the original creditor to get the documents in evidence.

I don’t even need somebody’s been trained in the document. I just, you got the documents, right? You got it, you own them. And I, you know, there’s a whole line, you know, there’s a, we could do a whole story on getting evident, an old podcast on getting evidence, evidence into evidence. But Juries, I’ve yet, I’ve yet to meet a juror who thinks, well, I pay my bills. He doesn’t have to pay his, you know, maybe back in the day when there was a problem and they were having issues of the defense or turning it through a lot of garbage at the wall. They go, you know what?

I’m okay with him not paying his bill. But it doesn’t happen now. That was like, show me your collection notes. See, who cares? You know, if you’ve made a mistake, look, and if there’s an error, I’m going to say, hey, Bill, we got our gin or we got a problem here. You know, this is, this is going to be an issue for you. It’s a real response. Mistakes have it. Sometimes you say, you know what? Yeah, it’s a mistake, but it’s not a fatal mistake. It’s in bona fide error defense. Sometimes it’s like, yeah, what are we going to do here? You know, you really, let’s, let’s get the,

well, how quickly can we get this resolved? But it’s a real reason. I’m not just doing it to get rid of them. I’m doing it to protect the client. And I think that a lot of that comes down to kind of our, the same thing, right? Like the ship is a lot tighter than it was, you know, 20 years ago. And I think now we’re dealing with an industry and debt buyers that are far better versed in their documentation. The technology has improved exponentially. The ability to manage the vast volumes of documentation. And if you consider how data management has evolved over the last 15, 20 years as

well, I think it all plays in quite nicely. Well, Michael, it sounds like you’ve got a lot of insights to be sharing with our industry into the future. And I really appreciate you coming on and sharing some of those insights with our audience. Oh, thank you. Hey, I love to talk about this stuff. I shockingly, I don’t know how it became a passion. Like I said, at the beginning, I sort of fell into this role and it just grew. And it’s it’s I could tell you when I quit, I even got calls from some of the defense bar, say, Hey, would you be willing to come to this side of the fence?

You know, you want to go to the dark side or the course, they call the light side, but whatever. And I’m like, no, I just can’t see myself doing the work you do. I’ve taken too much passion into where I’m at and what I do to just say that doesn’t matter. I was all fake. And, you know, I’m here because and I’ve gotten this far because I really like what I do. And I’m really passionate about what I do. And I think that the industry is a is an important one. And they’re they’re reasonable and they’re very ethical. You know, I don’t know what happened in 2010 and I don’t care and the

robust signings and all that stuff. I know what I see now. And I know when I talk to my clients, they’re there to make sure it’s done right. And if it’s not done right, they’re there to get it correct. So very happy it. Well, for those of you that are watching, if you have additional questions, you’d like to ask Michael or myself, you can leave those in the comments below and will be responding to those on LinkedIn and YouTube. If you have additional topics that you like to see us cover, you can leave those in the comments below as well. And hopefully I’ll be able to get Michael to come back at least one more time

to help me continue creating great content for a great industry. But until next time, Michael, thank you so much for coming on. I really appreciate your insights. Thank you. I really appreciate it being here. Thank you. And for those of you watching, we’ll see you again soon. Thanks, everybody.

About Guest

About Company

Trade Credit & Liquidity Management (TCLM)

Trade Credit & Liquidity Management (TCLM) is an independent resource focused on trade credit, working capital, liquidity, and the broader quote-to-cash process. Its content includes practical analysis, industry developments, technology trends, and resources for credit, treasury, finance, and receivables professionals.

Learn More

Related Videos